Oklahoma ELA 11.3.R.5

ELA11th GradeReading

The Standard

Students will evaluate how authors writing on the same issue reached different conclusions because of differences in assumptions, evidence, reasoning, and viewpoints, including examining rhetorical appeals, bias, and use of logical fallacies.

Oklahoma Academic Standards for English Language Arts (2021)

Teacher's field guide

What This Standard Means

What Students Need to Do

Students read two arguments about the same issue and explain why the writers disagree. They check each writer's assumptions, evidence, and reasoning. They also spot viewpoint, rhetorical appeals, bias, and faulty logic.

What Mastery Looks Like

A student points to a line in each text that shows an assumption or viewpoint. They compare how the writers use evidence to reach different conclusions. They explain how an appeal or fallacy affects an argument.

Common Misconceptions

Students may treat different conclusions as proof that one writer is lying. They may mistake a strong feeling for evidence or call any opinion a fallacy. They may spot bias only in the writer they disagree with.

How to Assess It

Exit ticket: Compare 'Ban phones: our class survey found fewer distractions without them' with 'Keep phones: families need emergency contact.' Name each writer's assumption, then explain which claim offers evidence and which needs more.

Lesson moves

Ways to Teach It

  1. Give pairs two short editorials on school phone bans and colored pencils; have them mark claims, evidence, assumptions, and emotional appeals.

  2. Ask, 'What does each writer assume about phone access, and how does that shape the conclusion?' Require one quoted line from each text.

  3. Deal teams short argument cards; have them sort each into evidence, emotional appeal, false dilemma, or hasty generalization and defend one choice.

  4. Read two public comments about a proposed school phone ban; write how each speaker's stake in the decision affects their argument.

Free download

Printable 11.3.R.5 Worksheet

Preview of the 11.3.R.5 printable worksheet

A ready-to-print activity worksheet aligned to 11.3.R.5, with an answer key for the teacher on its own page. No account needed.

PDF, US Letter, prints cleanly in black and white.

Download the worksheet

Keep exploring

Related Standards

Turn this exact standard into a lesson

Grade, subject, topic, and the complete standard are prefilled. Create one free, no account needed.

Also for this standard:Make a WorksheetMake a QuizMake a Sub Lesson