Alabama Math FM.FD.A.22.a

MathGrades 9–12Fairness and Democracy

The Standard

FM.FD.A
Various methods for determining a winner in a voting system can result in paradoxes or other issues of fairness.
FM.FD.A.22
Analyze advantages and disadvantages of different types of ballot voting systems.
Identify impacts of using a preferential ballot voting system and compare it to single candidate voting and other voting systems.

2019 Alabama Course of Study: Mathematics · Various methods for determining a winner in a voting system can result in paradoxes or other issues of fairness.

Teacher's field guide

What This Standard Means

What Students Need to Do

Students count first-choice votes on a set of ballots. They also transfer votes when a candidate is eliminated and award points to ranked choices. Then they compare the winners and explain why the methods give different results.

What Mastery Looks Like

A student can tally the same ballots using plurality, ranked choice, and Borda points. They can explain a difference in winners using first-choice votes, transferred votes, or second-place support.

Common Misconceptions

Some students think the candidate with the most first-choice votes must win every method. Others transfer eliminated ballots to the wrong candidate or treat Borda points as another elimination round.

How to Assess It

Give students these ballots: 4 A>C>B, 3 B>C>A, and 2 C>A>B. Ask for the plurality, ranked-choice, and Borda winners, using 2, 1, and 0 points for Borda, plus one sentence explaining C's Borda win.

Lesson moves

Ways to Teach It

  1. Hand out 4 A>B>C, 3 B>C>A, and 2 C>B>A paper ballots; have groups count first choices, then transfer C's ballots.

  2. Ask: A wins the first-choice count, but B wins after C's votes transfer. Which result seems fairer, and why?

  3. In pairs, race to tally 4 A>C>B, 3 B>C>A, and 2 C>A>B ballots by plurality, ranked choice, and Borda points.

  4. Vote on three class fundraiser options with ranked paper ballots, then compare plurality and ranked-choice winners before choosing one.

Free download

Printable FM.FD.A.22.a Worksheet

Preview of the FM.FD.A.22.a printable worksheet

A ready-to-print activity worksheet aligned to FM.FD.A.22.a, with an answer key for the teacher on its own page. No account needed.

PDF, US Letter, prints cleanly in black and white.

Download the worksheet

Keep exploring

Related Standards

Turn this exact standard into a lesson

Grade, subject, topic, and the complete standard are prefilled. Create one free, no account needed.

Also for this standard:Make a WorksheetMake a QuizMake a Sub Lesson